A Practical Guide to Summary Administration in Fall Branch, Tennessee
Summary administration is a streamlined probate process available in Tennessee for certain smaller estates or where the will provides for it. This guide explains how summary administration works in Fall Branch and Washington County, including who qualifies, what paperwork is required, and typical timelines. We aim to give clear, local-focused information so families can make informed choices when handling an estate. If you are preparing to settle a loved one’s affairs or planning in advance, understanding the summary administration pathway can reduce delay and simplify the transfer of assets under Tennessee law.
Many families seek a probate route that reduces time and court involvement while preserving the legal safeguards needed for asset transfer. Summary administration can be appropriate when the decedent’s estate meets statutory value limits or when the will explicitly authorizes a simplified procedure. This page covers practical steps, common documents, and how local courts in Washington County often handle filings. We also highlight considerations that may affect whether summary administration is the best path, and how careful planning can prevent complications for heirs and beneficiaries.
Why Summary Administration Can Be Beneficial for Families in Fall Branch
Choosing summary administration can reduce time in probate, lower filing requirements, and limit court appearances compared with full probate proceedings. For estates that meet Tennessee’s conditions, this approach helps heirs receive assets more quickly and with fewer formalities, which can ease financial and emotional burdens after a death. It remains important to confirm eligibility, as incorrect use of summary administration could cause delays or disputes. Working with knowledgeable legal counsel familiar with local court practices in Washington County can help ensure the process is handled correctly and that deadlines and notices are observed.
About Jay Johnson Law Firm and Our Work with Summary Administration
Jay Johnson Law Firm assists families throughout Tennessee, including residents near Fall Branch and Washington County, with estate planning and probate matters. Our attorneys and staff are familiar with the local probate courts and common estate issues that arise in smaller estates. We provide practical guidance on eligibility for summary administration, assist with preparing and filing required documents, and communicate with beneficiaries and creditors as needed. Our goal is to manage procedural requirements efficiently so families can focus on closing this chapter with dignity and minimal disruption to their day-to-day lives.
Understanding Summary Administration Under Tennessee Law
Summary administration is a statutory probate pathway in Tennessee designed for estates that meet certain criteria, typically involving limited asset value or specific types of property. This simplified process reduces formal court procedures compared with a full probate estate, and in many cases requires fewer filings and hearings. Eligibility can be based on the total value of probate assets, the presence of a small intestate estate, or explicit authorization in the will. It is important to review Tennessee statutes and local court rules, and to confirm current thresholds and requirements with the probate clerk in Washington County before proceeding.
Although summary administration streamlines many steps, it still requires accurate inventorying of assets, proper notice to beneficiaries and creditors when necessary, and filing the right documents with the county probate court. Failure to follow procedure can result in delays or disputes among heirs. The process typically moves faster than full probate but must be handled with attention to timelines and legal notice requirements. Families should consider whether assets such as jointly held property, payable-on-death accounts, or trusts change the need for any probate action in their specific situation.
What Summary Administration Means in Practice
In practice, summary administration allows for a condensed probate process that focuses on transferring certain assets without the full suite of probate procedures. It is often used when the estate’s probate assets fall below a statutory limit or when the will expressly allows a shortened procedure. The estate representative may submit a simplified petition to the court, provide an inventory of qualifying assets, and follow local notice rules. The court can then approve distribution with less formality. While the process is simpler, it still creates an authoritative record for title transfers and bank distributions, ensuring heirs receive property under court-approved terms.
Key Steps and Elements of Summary Administration
Core elements of summary administration include confirming eligibility, preparing and filing a petition or affidavit, inventorying probate assets, and submitting required notices. The probate clerk in Washington County will guide filing requirements and provide the necessary forms or local instructions. After review, the court may issue an order authorizing distribution according to the will or state law. Throughout the process, attention to creditor claims, tax matters, and proper documentation of transfers is necessary to prevent later challenges. Clear communication with beneficiaries helps manage expectations about timing and responsibilities.
Key Terms and Glossary for Summary Administration
Understanding common terms helps families navigate the summary administration process more confidently. Definitions for terms like probate estate, decedent, personal representative, inventory, and petition clarify roles and paperwork. Familiarity with these concepts makes it easier to comply with court rules and to communicate with institutions holding assets. The following glossary entries explain the most frequently encountered words and phrases in plain language tailored to Tennessee practice, focusing on how each term affects the simplified probate path and the steps required to transfer assets to heirs.
Probate Estate
The probate estate consists of the assets that must pass through the probate process because they are owned solely by the decedent at death and have no beneficiary designations, joint owners, or trust provisions that transfer them automatically. Examples can include certain bank accounts, personal property, or real estate titled only in the decedent’s name. Determining the scope of the probate estate is a key step in assessing whether summary administration is available. Locating titles, account agreements, and beneficiary designations helps in preparing an accurate inventory for the court.
Personal Representative
A personal representative is the individual appointed by the court to administer the estate during probate, also sometimes called an executor when named in a will. In summary administration, the personal representative has responsibility for collecting probate assets, paying valid debts and expenses, and distributing remaining property to heirs or beneficiaries according to the will or Tennessee intestacy law. Even in a simplified process, the personal representative must follow legal requirements and ensure that transfers are documented to prevent future disputes over ownership.
Inventory
An inventory is a formal list of the probate assets, including descriptions and approximate values, submitted to the probate court as part of the administration process. For summary administration, the inventory helps court personnel determine eligibility and authorize distributions. Accurate inventories should include real property, bank accounts, personal items of value, and other assets that lack automatic beneficiary designations. Careful documentation, such as account statements or deeds, supports the inventory and assists in smooth transfers to heirs.
Affidavit or Simplified Petition
An affidavit or simplified petition is the filing used to initiate summary administration in many jurisdictions, stating the estate facts and asserting eligibility for the streamlined process. This document outlines the decedent’s basic information, lists probate assets, and requests the court’s approval for distribution. The form often includes statements about notice to interested parties and declarations regarding debts. Preparing a clear and complete petition reduces follow-up questions from the court and supports timely closure of the estate.
Comparing Summary Administration and Full Probate
Choosing between summary administration and full probate depends on estate size, asset types, creditor issues, and whether the will allows a simplified path. Summary administration is typically faster and involves fewer formalities, making it appealing for smaller estates. Full probate covers a broader set of procedures and is often necessary when the estate includes complex assets, disputes among heirs, or significant creditor claims. Evaluating the specific facts of an estate, including how assets are titled and any outstanding obligations, helps determine the most appropriate legal route for settlement.
When a Simplified Probate Process May Be Appropriate:
Estate Value Falls Within Statutory Limits
Summary administration can be suitable when the total probate estate value falls below the threshold set by Tennessee law or local rules. When estate assets meet that limit, the filings required by the court are typically reduced, and the overall process is streamlined. It is important to verify current statutory values and to include all probate assets when assessing eligibility. Seeking guidance on calculating estate value ensures the right procedure is pursued, and prevents surprises if the court requires a full administration due to undisclosed assets or valuation discrepancies.
Will Provides for a Shortened Process
Some wills include provisions that allow the personal representative to seek a shortened probate process when conditions are met. When a decedent’s will authorizes summary administration or similar streamlined procedures, the court can follow those instructions so long as they conform to statutory requirements. This can simplify estate settlement and reduce the administrative burden on heirs. Confirming that the will’s language complies with Tennessee probate rules and clearly supports a simplified petition is an important step before filing with the probate court.
Why a More Detailed Probate Approach May Be Necessary:
Complex Assets or Title Issues
When an estate includes assets such as business interests, real estate with unresolved title matters, or accounts without clear beneficiary designations, a fuller probate process may be required to protect the estate’s value and ensure lawful transfer. Those complexities often demand additional documentation, possible creditor negotiations, and court oversight to resolve competing claims. Taking time to assess asset types and ownership records before choosing a simplified route can prevent complications and help families select the proper legal pathway for distributing property under Tennessee law.
Disputes Among Heirs or Creditors
If there are disagreements between beneficiaries, potential claims from creditors, or unclear beneficiary designations, a more comprehensive probate administration helps provide a formal process for resolving issues. The fuller procedure includes broader notice requirements, opportunities for objections, and a structured timeline for addressing claims and disputes. Handling contested matters through the appropriate channels helps protect the estate and ensures distributions occur in accordance with court orders, reducing the risk of later litigation that can prolong resolution and increase costs.
Benefits of Choosing the Right Probate Path for Your Situation
Selecting the appropriate probate path — whether summary administration or full probate — offers benefits based on the estate’s size and complexity. A well-chosen approach minimizes delays, reduces unnecessary paperwork, and aligns proceedings with legal requirements for creditor notice and asset transfer. For families in Fall Branch, aligning the legal process with the estate’s specific circumstances helps avoid costly corrections later. Taking time to assess the estate thoroughly ensures that all parties are treated fairly and that property transfers are properly recorded to avoid title issues down the road.
A methodical approach to estate settlement protects both heirs and the personal representative by documenting decisions and creating an official court record. Whether that record comes from a simplified summary administration order or a full probate decree, it provides the authority institutions require to release funds, transfer real estate, and close accounts. Ensuring that procedural requirements are satisfied reduces the likelihood of future challenges and helps families conclude estate matters with clarity and finality, preserving peace of mind and safeguarding assets for intended beneficiaries.
Faster Asset Distribution When Appropriate
One significant advantage of summary administration is that it can enable quicker distribution of property when the estate qualifies. By limiting formalities and focusing on the essential documentation, the probate process can move more swiftly, allowing beneficiaries to receive funds or property sooner. Faster distribution can ease immediate financial pressures on family members and help settle ongoing obligations. It is important to confirm eligibility and follow all notice and documentation rules so that speed does not come at the expense of legal protection or proper record-keeping.
Reduced Court Involvement and Lower Administrative Burden
When appropriate, a simplified probate route reduces the amount of paperwork and court appearances required of the personal representative and beneficiaries. This can lower administrative burdens and decrease legal costs associated with longer proceedings. Families often appreciate a process that allows them to settle an estate with minimal disruption. However, even with a reduced burden, maintaining accurate records and satisfying creditor and beneficiary notification requirements remains essential to ensure the estate is closed properly and to prevent future claims or disputes.
Practice Areas
Top Searched Keywords
- summary administration Fall Branch TN
- Tennessee summary administration process
- small estate probate Washington County
- probate alternatives Fall Branch
- estate administration Tennessee courts
- simplified probate Tennessee
- personal representative duties Tennessee
- transfer of assets after death TN
- summary probate attorney near Fall Branch
Practical Tips for Handling Summary Administration
Confirm Eligibility Early
Start by reviewing the estate inventory and any applicable statutes to confirm whether the estate meets Tennessee’s thresholds for summary administration. Early verification prevents wasted effort on an approach that may later be rejected by the court and helps you collect required documents promptly. Check titles, beneficiary designations, and account ownership so that all probate assets are identified. Communicating with the probate clerk in Washington County can provide clarity on required forms and local expectations, making the filing process smoother from the outset.
Prepare Accurate Documentation
Communicate Clear Expectations with Beneficiaries
Maintaining open communication with heirs and beneficiaries can help prevent misunderstandings and objections that delay the process. Explain the anticipated timeline, required documents, and the simplified nature of the proceeding when summary administration is used. Provide copies of filings and orders as appropriate and respond promptly to reasonable questions. Clear documentation and transparency about decisions build trust and reduce the chances of conflict that might otherwise require a more formal probate process to resolve.
Why Fall Branch Families Consider Summary Administration
Families often consider summary administration as a way to settle an estate more quickly when the probate assets are limited or when the will allows a shortened process. This route can limit court involvement, reduce procedural steps, and help heirs obtain assets in a timely manner. It is particularly attractive when property titles are straightforward and there are no expected creditor disputes. Still, confirming eligibility and preparing accurate documentation remains important, as the simplified path is only appropriate under specific statutory or will-based conditions in Tennessee.
Another reason families choose a simplified procedure is to minimize administrative burden and associated costs. Completing a streamlined filing can be less time-consuming and less expensive than full probate, which benefits families who need prompt resolution. However, some estates require fuller probate due to asset complexity or potential disputes, so weighing the estate’s particular facts ensures the right decision. Thoughtful planning and local knowledge of Washington County procedures help families avoid delays and make sure distributions are handled lawfully and respectfully.
Common Situations Where Summary Administration Is Used
Typical scenarios that lead families to pursue summary administration include estates with low total probate value, decedents whose wills allow a short-form procedure, or intestate estates with limited assets. It is also used when most property already passes outside probate through joint ownership, beneficiary designations, or trusts, leaving only a small amount to be administered. Each situation requires careful review to verify that the remaining assets qualify for the simplified process and that required notices are issued to any interested parties under Tennessee law.
Small Probate Asset Base
When the estate’s probate assets are minimal, summary administration can reduce paperwork and court time while still providing an official court order to transfer property. This situation often applies when most assets transfer automatically or when the decedent’s personal property and accounts subject to probate fall below statutory limits. Even for small estates, accurate documentation of asset ownership and values is essential to prevent future challenges and to satisfy institutions that require a court order before releasing funds or transferring titles.
Will Authorizes Shortened Process
If the decedent’s will specifically authorizes a shortened administration process when appropriate, the personal representative may use that provision to seek summary administration. Such language can simplify filings so long as it complies with Tennessee law. Confirming that the will’s direction aligns with statutory requirements and the court’s expectations helps prevent delays. Having clear testamentary instructions can reduce uncertainty for heirs and support a more efficient conclusion to the estate’s administration.
Most Assets Transfer Outside Probate
When the bulk of assets pass outside probate through mechanisms like joint tenancy or beneficiary designations, only a small subset of property may require court action. Summary administration can address that limited set of assets without initiating a full probate. It is important to document which items are subject to probate and which transfer automatically, providing appropriate evidence to the court. This focused approach reduces administrative tasks while ensuring that probate-only assets are distributed correctly under applicable law.
Local Probate Assistance for Fall Branch and Washington County
Jay Johnson Law Firm serves families in Fall Branch and surrounding areas, offering guidance through Tennessee probate processes including summary administration. We help identify qualifying assets, prepare required filings, and coordinate with the probate clerk to move the case forward. Our approach centers on clear communication with family members and timely completion of procedural steps. If you need assistance organizing documents, assessing eligibility, or preparing petitions and inventories, we provide practical support tailored to local court practices and the needs of Washington County residents.
Why Families Choose Our Firm for Summary Administration Matters
Families choose our firm because we focus on practical solutions that address the specific facts of each estate. We assist clients in identifying probate assets, completing accurate inventories, and preparing petitions consistent with Tennessee law. Our goal is to streamline the process while ensuring required notices and court formalities are met, helping avoid delays or procedural errors that could prolong administration.
We also prioritize clear communication with beneficiaries and provide guidance on documentation needed by banks, title companies, and other institutions to release assets. By anticipating common document requests and court inquiries, we help reduce back-and-forth and keep the process moving. Clients benefit from a practical, organized approach tailored to the local probate environment in Washington County and Fall Branch.
Throughout the administration process, we work to address creditor notices, submit required paperwork promptly, and support the personal representative in fulfilling statutory duties. Our focus is on helping families reach a lawful and timely resolution so assets can be transferred with minimal friction and with respect for the decedent’s wishes and applicable Tennessee rules.
Contact Jay Johnson Law Firm for Help with Summary Administration in Fall Branch
How We Handle Summary Administration Filings and Court Interaction
Our process begins with an initial review of the decedent’s documents and a preliminary assessment of whether summary administration is appropriate under Tennessee law. We then assist in gathering supporting documentation, preparing the petition or affidavit, and filing with the Washington County probate court. We coordinate notices to interested parties and address creditor issues as they arise. When the court issues its order, we help with transfers of title and bank account distributions. This organized approach seeks to reduce delays and ensure proper closure.
Step One: Case Intake and Eligibility Review
During intake, we collect the decedent’s will if available, account statements, deeds, and beneficiary information to evaluate the assets subject to probate. This review establishes whether summary administration is an appropriate path and identifies any complicating factors such as unresolved title issues or potential creditor claims. Early assessment helps set expectations for timing and documentation requirements for filings with the probate court and prepares beneficiaries for what to expect during administration.
Document Collection and Asset Identification
Collecting accurate records is foundational to a successful filing. We assist in locating account statements, vehicle titles, deeds, and any beneficiary designations that affect asset transfer. Clarifying which items are probate property and which pass outside probate avoids surprises and supports a complete inventory. Thorough documentation also makes it easier to satisfy bank and title company requirements when transferring property or closing accounts.
Pre-Filing Eligibility Assessment
Before preparing a petition, we evaluate the total probate asset value against Tennessee thresholds and check for any will provisions that allow a shortened process. This step helps determine whether summary administration is the correct route and prevents unnecessary filings that the court might reject. Identifying potential creditor claims or disputes at this stage allows us to recommend the most appropriate approach for settling the estate efficiently and lawfully.
Step Two: Preparing and Filing the Petition
Once eligibility is confirmed, the next step is drafting a clear petition or affidavit and compiling the supporting inventory and documentation required by the probate court. We prepare the necessary forms in accordance with local rules and submit them to the Washington County probate clerk. Properly prepared filings reduce back-and-forth with the court and promote a timely review process. We also prepare notices for beneficiaries and other interested parties when required, ensuring compliance with legal notice obligations.
Drafting a Complete Petition
A complete petition or affidavit provides the court with all relevant facts about the decedent, the proposed personal representative, and a clear listing of probate assets. We include supporting documentation such as a certified death certificate, the will if applicable, and statements evidencing account balances or property ownership. Clear presentation of facts and documentation helps the court make a prompt determination regarding the simplified administration request.
Notices and Creditor Handling
When required, we prepare and issue notices to beneficiaries and creditors in accordance with Tennessee rules. Addressing creditor claims and providing proper notice reduces the risk of later objections and preserves the integrity of distributions. We monitor any responses from creditors and assist in resolving claims so that the court can approve final distribution without outstanding disputes that could delay closure of the estate.
Step Three: Court Order and Asset Distribution
After the court reviews the petition and supporting documents, it may issue an order authorizing distribution under summary administration. Once the order is entered, we assist with handing court-approved documentation to banks, title companies, and other institutions to effect transfers and close accounts. We ensure distributions follow the will or Tennessee intestacy rules and provide the personal representative with guidance on completing required filings so the estate is formally closed.
Obtaining Court Authorization
The court order validates the authority to transfer assets to heirs or beneficiaries under the simplified procedure. We confirm that the order addresses all items included in the inventory and provides the documentation institutions require for releases. Having a clear order helps avoid future title disputes and provides an official record that the estate was settled in accordance with Tennessee law and court approval.
Final Transfers and Closing the Estate
With the court order in hand, we coordinate final steps including presenting required documents to banks, recording deeds if real property transfers, and ensuring all distributions are accurately recorded. We then prepare any final court forms necessary to close the estate and provide beneficiaries with documentation of transfers. Proper closing steps protect both heirs and the personal representative by creating a written record of the administration and the basis for distributions.
Frequently Asked Questions About Summary Administration in Fall Branch
What is summary administration and who qualifies in Tennessee?
Summary administration is a streamlined probate option under Tennessee law for certain estates that meet statutory conditions or when a will authorizes a shortened process. It reduces procedural steps compared with full probate and often requires fewer filings and hearings. Eligibility typically depends on the total value of probate assets or specific provisions in the decedent’s will. Confirming eligibility with the Washington County probate court is an early step to determine whether the simplified path is available.Even though the process is shorter, it still requires accurate documentation and proper notifications. The personal representative must inventory probate assets, submit the required petition or affidavit, and comply with any notice requirements to beneficiaries and creditors. Ensuring all procedural obligations are met helps avoid delays and supports a lawful transfer of assets to heirs.
How long does summary administration typically take in Washington County?
Timelines for summary administration vary depending on court schedules, completeness of filings, and whether objections or creditor claims arise. In many straightforward cases, the process can be completed more quickly than full probate, sometimes within a matter of weeks to a few months. Local court caseload and the need for additional documentation can extend that timeline. Contacting the probate clerk in Washington County provides the most current information about local processing times.Preparation plays a significant role in timing. Ensuring the petition is complete, providing accurate inventories, and promptly responding to any court requests will help move the case forward. If disputes or creditor issues emerge, additional time may be required to resolve those matters before the court will authorize final distribution.
What documents are needed to start a summary administration case?
Beginning a summary administration case usually requires a certified death certificate, the decedent’s will if one exists, documentation of assets such as deeds and account statements, and a completed petition or affidavit stating eligibility for the simplified process. A detailed inventory of probate assets and any required notices to beneficiaries or creditors should accompany the filing. Local forms and filing requirements can be confirmed with the Washington County probate clerk.Gathering documentation ahead of time reduces delays in filing. Verifying account titles, beneficiary designations, and ownership records helps clarify which assets are subject to probate. Providing complete supporting documentation with the petition minimizes follow-up from the court and improves the chances of a swift review and order for distribution.
Will creditors still have a chance to make claims under summary administration?
Creditors generally retain the right to present claims against the estate even when summary administration is used, although notice and claim procedures may differ from full probate. The personal representative must follow Tennessee notice requirements and address legitimate claims in accordance with statutory timelines. Proper handling of creditor notices protects the estate and reduces the risk of future claims against beneficiaries or the personal representative.If a creditor submits a valid claim, the personal representative may need to resolve it before the court approves final distribution. This can extend the timeline and, depending on the claim’s nature, require allocation of estate assets to satisfy obligations. Early identification of potential creditor issues helps manage expectations and supports orderly administration.
Can real estate be transferred using summary administration?
Real estate can be transferred through summary administration when the property is part of the probate estate and the simplified process is appropriate under Tennessee law. Transferring real estate typically requires an order from the probate court and may involve recording a deed reflecting the court-authorized transfer. Ensuring clear title and resolving any liens or encumbrances before or during the process helps prevent problems when transferring property to heirs.Because real estate transactions often involve additional steps like recording deeds and satisfying mortgage obligations, careful documentation and coordination with the county recorder’s office or title company are important. Working through these steps with attention to local practices in Washington County helps ensure a smooth transfer once the court issues its order.
What happens if a will contains contradictory instructions about simplified probate?
If a will contains language that appears to conflict with statutory rules for simplified probate, the court will interpret the will in light of Tennessee law. In some cases, language that attempts to bypass required procedures may not be effective if it contradicts statutory protections or notice requirements. The probate court evaluates whether the will’s instructions can be implemented within the legal framework for summary administration.When ambiguity exists, it may be necessary to seek clarification through the court or pursue full probate to address conflicting provisions. Clarifying testamentary language during estate planning can prevent such issues, and reviewing the will with knowledgeable counsel helps ensure instructions align with legal procedures available in the jurisdiction.
How are beneficiaries notified in a summary administration proceeding?
Beneficiaries are typically notified through the methods required by Tennessee law and the local probate court when summary administration is pursued. Notices may be mailed or otherwise served, and certain interested parties must receive copies of filings or orders. Proper notification gives beneficiaries an opportunity to review filings and raise any concerns or objections within the allowed timeframe.Maintaining clear communication with beneficiaries beyond formal notices helps manage expectations and reduces the likelihood of disputes. Providing copies of key filings and being transparent about the timeline and any creditor issues fosters cooperation and can streamline the administration process for all involved.
Is there a minimum estate value required to use summary administration?
There is not necessarily a single statewide minimum estate value that triggers summary administration; rather, eligibility depends on statutory thresholds and local rules that define when a simplified process is appropriate. These thresholds can relate to the total value of probate assets or to specific conditions stated in a will. Checking current Tennessee statutes and Washington County probate requirements is important to determine whether summary administration applies in a particular case.Because thresholds and procedures can change, early consultation with the probate clerk or a local attorney helps confirm eligibility. Proper valuation of assets and a clear accounting of what must pass through probate are important steps in assessing whether a simplified process is available and advisable.
Can a personal representative be removed during summary administration?
A personal representative can be removed by the court if they fail to perform their duties, mismanage assets, or if removal is otherwise warranted under Tennessee law. Even in a simplified administration, fiduciary responsibilities apply, and interested parties may petition the court to remove a personal representative for cause. The court will evaluate whether removal is necessary to protect the estate or beneficiaries’ interests.To avoid disputes, personal representatives should keep accurate records, communicate with beneficiaries, and follow statutory procedures for notice and creditor handling. Acting transparently and in good faith reduces the risk of removal proceedings and supports an efficient administration process for the estate.
How can families prepare in advance to minimize probate issues?
Families can prepare in advance by organizing financial records, updating beneficiary designations on accounts and insurance policies, and considering whether property should be titled to avoid probate when appropriate. Creating a clear will and discussing final wishes with family members reduces confusion and supports a smoother transition. Keeping important documents accessible and informing a trusted individual of their location helps speed administration when needed.Regularly reviewing estate documents and account titles ensures that beneficiary designations remain current and that assets pass as intended. Thoughtful planning reduces the likelihood that a full probate will be required and can make summary administration more effective when that route is appropriate for the estate’s circumstances.